- Cologne 99ers: 2005-2006
- Alba Berlino: 2007-2008
- Cologne 99ers: 2004
- Alba Berlino: 2009
- Cologne 99ers: 2006
- Alba Berlino: 2008
- CBA Rookie of the Year (2003)
- CBA All-Defensive First Team (2004)
- CBA All-Rookie First Team (2003)
- USBL Defensive Player of the Year (2004)
- All-USBL First Team (2004)
- 2 volte USBL All-Defensive Team (2003, 2004)
- Bundesliga Import Player of the Year (2006)
- Basketball-Bundesliga MVP finals: 1
- RheinEnergie Köln: 2005-2006
- Alba Berlino: 2009-10
-
- (EN) Immanuel McElroy, su Basketball-reference.com, Sports Reference LLC.
- (EN) Immanuel McElroy, su eurobasket.com, Eurobasket Inc.
- (EN) Immanuel McElroy, su euroleague.net, ULEB.
- (EN) Immanuel McElroy (NCAA), su Sports-reference.com, Sports Reference LLC.
- (EN) Immanuel McElroy, su realgm.com, RealGM LLC.
- (DE) Immanuel McElroy, su easycredit-bbl.de, Basketball-Bundesliga.