Discussione:Pace di Ramla
Ultimo commento: 3 anni fa, lasciato da Cloj in merito all'argomento Wrong location, Jaffa, not Ramla?
Questa voce contiene una traduzione, completa o parziale, della voce originale:
«Treaty of Ramla» tratta da Wikipedia in inglese.
Consulta la cronologia della pagina originale per conoscere l'elenco degli autori.
«Treaty of Ramla» tratta da Wikipedia in inglese.
Consulta la cronologia della pagina originale per conoscere l'elenco degli autori.
Wrong location, Jaffa, not Ramla? modifica
All serious Western sources seem to place the signing of the treaty at Jaffa, not Ramla. Are there good, primary or secondary Arabic sources talking of a September 1192 treaty in Ramla? Please do help out with such information, if possible also on the English or German talk page - but only with trustworthy chronicles or academic papers; Axelrod's book is not a good source. Thank you very much. Arminden (msg) 14:24, 21 giu 2020 (CEST)
- Thank you. It could be a mistake to cite Ramla instead of Jaffa (but it seems difficult to me that the agreement was reached in Jaffa, in the hands of the King of England Richard the Lionhearth a few days ago).
- In any case, I do not contest that Axelrod's work can be considered unsatisfactory as a source, but I expect at least to indicate kindly the historical source for which the truce agreement would not have been reached in Ramla. Best regards. --Cloj 17:10, 25 giu 2020 (CEST)